Post by April on Aug 19, 2004 12:58:48 GMT -8
This thread contains all of the feedback I've gotten from the GOAYB board at PB Support.
** V1 Feedback **
{the original version of CYN}
Screenshot for reference, salvaged from the Wayback Machine & my archived files:
(CLICK FOR FULL-VIEW)
(CLICK FOR FULL-VIEW)
Legend said:
Now that is one of the most beautiful sites I've ever seen. Well done!! Everything is customized and flows well. You've done some good work here, babygurl. This should be an example for others to follow. Nice work![Legend]
~LoA said:
Great Forum! Join up people! you wont regret it![LoA]
conqueringwolf said:
yea....do i have to turn all my nuts in to the admin when i join? LOL....great board babygurl!!!
[ConqueringWolf]
» said:
hi babygurl! nice work 10/10[Bay B Gurl]
Luca said:
quality board fo sho.[Luca]
Pyroend said:
I don't think any nuts should be cracked now or ever. Anyway not a bad site 8/10[Pyroend]
Samus32755879 said:
Lookin very nice babygal. [Samus32755879]
Lumiance® said:
100%An excellent site you got there. Very orignal and active. I'm actually going to join it.
[Lumiance]
praetoritevong said:
Babygurl:
You misspelled proboards in your link... took me a sec to figure that out ^^ Anyways... I must say that brown and the mod name styles in the shell smasher column put me off a little... Your images are of very high quality; those are really good. I think that the menu buttons are a tad plain compared to the rest of the images, but good nonetheless. I like your customized stuff (crack your nuts, etc.)! 8.5/10
Again, great job!
[praetoritevong]
Cleo said:
Something about the name makes me smirk. :3
The side.. thing of the background is the only downfall, really, other than that it's pretty nice.
The customs are also quite nice. ^^
9/10
[Cleo]
Wolfwood said:
What a strange title for a board, I must say. Anyway, the layout you have there is really good. I can see you put a lot of work into it.
10/10
[Wolfwood]
xkamelx said:
I've basicaly watched this forum grow since April, and grow it has, into a beautiful site, one of the better sites ProBoards has to offer!!Come see what I'm talking about!
[xkamelx]
Andree said:
Ok sounds good.
++ Orignal Title
+++ Great and interesting content
+ Great graphics
+ Nice amouny of activty
- Affiliate Table is going to fast and it makes it hard to see them. It also makes me a bit dizzy.
A Excellent job. That's one incredible forum.
[Andree]
Erazer said:
A very great, unique forum you have there, i don't think i have ever seen a forum out there like that before, which is a good thing because it makes yours stand out from the others - something different.You have got the colours, designs and images to perfection. The custom text is very effective also.
Nice work and well done 10/10
[Erazer]
Carpy said:
top marks »babygurl« splendid forum. well done. [Carpy]
ConqueringWolf said:
Nice babygurl....you have some of the best colors i have seen on a board....all very mellow and relaxing...your board just seems to ooze and flow....all your icons and graphics match everything perfectly....u have an amazing banner....i really cant think of anything to suggest that would make it any better [ConqueringWolf]
Xylish said:
Lol, a humourous name, lovely designed board. Crack your nuts sure has the highest quality of contents of many active crunchers [Xylish]
Dillson said:
Bloody brilliant forum, as I've always said. I love the fact that it doesn't care about being like all the other boards. It's not grey, it's not boring, and it's certainly not ordinary. It's unique, it's individualistic and it's worth all of your time![Dillson]
Joe said:
I must say that is one of the most beautifulles (is that even a word? lol) website forums. Very nice looking. I'm hoping to get mine looking like that one of these days.out of 10 stars: 10 for the looks!
By the way, nice title of the forums. got a kick out of it.
[Joe]
Popojoe said:
Ouch...lolI love the forum! It look unique, the design as well and the name! I always recruncher that name, it is a very good pun you have there.
10/10
Sirius said:
Yup, everything is original, love the design, got some great active crunchers, it looks. Nothing really I can suggest.Overall: 10/10
[Popojoe]
johndoe said:
By far, teh funniest, most creative name of any proboard I have seen.
Ever.
As CW said, no complaints.
Its the best looking general forum out there.
[johndoe]
Madness said:
10/10 The title is a bit creepy but I like the site. It has good colors and it really matches the title. I think this site could be going places![Madness]
MichaelCole said:
You have an excellent banner and it paves the way to the theme of your forum. The menu icons look class and that goes well with your colour scheme and banner. The private message bar looks different and it also looks very good. The same can be said be said for your
Info Centre
On/Off icons
Coloured Scrollbard
Cell Highlight
To me you've got them pretty much covered and don't need to do anymore to it.
To Work On
You can pick up a better Info Centre look around one of proboards graphics boards to pick up a better info centre.
Also the above can apply to you getting a better affiliates table.
Keep going and good luck!
[MichaelCole]
LovelyFairy said:
I love the brown, and everything on here looks perfect!you have great codes! granets, banner, everything, no suggestions 10/10
[LovelyFairy]
Caryl said:
I think that's a really funny name for a forum, and the forum looks dazzling. My only real recommendation would be to change the gradients for your categories. I'm not sure how well they blend in with the rest of the boards. Other than that, I think it looks really nice and original! [Caryl]
Enchant said:
The name is an eye catcher...lol The banner is good....
the buttons, scroll bar, gradients, and icons are all good.....
the color scheme is good and matches the theme.....
your information box is nice....
Background is nice......
the text dynamic is cool.....
Cell highlights are good....
I think maybe a more updated info center might be better....
Over all is a fantastic looking forum.....congrats...
[Enchant]
* said:
This has to be the best forum names I have seen....lolyour board is excellent
pleny of different catagories to choose from
the design is great
and I can't think of any thing you could do better cause its so well done
just maybe you should avertise like crazy.
you could get thousands of crunchers if you did
great job 10/10
darkryu2 said:
Cracking nuts (like walnuts, or peanuts) doesn't hurt me at all, maybe to the nut but not me Pros
+I like the bg, you used..even though I don't know exactly what it is..leaves?
+You used nice, nutty colors
+I like the images you used, buttons, on/off icons etc.
Cons
-None
Good Job
[darkryu2]
secretrater said:
I am assuming... will you know...um what I mean. Back Off, for your rate, deal?FORUM: Crack Your Nuts
RATER: Drake
CONTENT: Wow! An active chillout place, rare today among ProBoards.
You got 10 points out of 10
CODING:
In Internet Explorer: No error
In FireFox: No error
One problem, the cell highlight does not work in Internet Explorer
It might be easier to locate CSS if you have all of them in one tag.
Please resize your forum a little, it'll be nice to see the side image.
You got 8 points out of 10
COLORS: YOur colors are very nice, and the CSS does a great job finishing the colors off. It is all very easy on the eyes.
You got 8 points out of 10
GRAPHICS: The graphics are mostly diffent. and They are very unique, good Job! Also they match the colors very well.
You got 10 points out of 10
APPEAL: The overall look is a KO in both IE and FF!
You got 8 points out of 10
OVERALL: You got a total of 44 points out of 50! Congrats. 8.8/10
Please PM me this link, I want to join when I have some time.
[secretrater]
tistheseason said:
Lol, first of all...i'm really liking the name and the slogan... Suggestions....
Hmm....none that I see....
Thumbs up....
I'm really liking the logo...the whole swirvy effect going on is pretty neat...with the bowl of nuts on the side...perfect placing...
I like the whole cracked top buttons you have, very nice and matches well with your theme...
The background is perfect in my opinion, oOo...spiral leaves and i'm not sure what is in between the spiral leaves, nuts? lol, it still fits with the theme....
I love the whole minimize effect it does when you pass by the links...lol, not sure what else to call it...the minimize effect...
The category seperator image is, again, thematic and goes well with the banner....
Overall, a unique forum that looks appealing on the eyes and fun topics to discuss
[tistheseason]
immortalironman said:
WOW! This is one awesome looking forum babygurl. I love your background, its simple, but that design on the side is simply wonderful. I like the gradients you have, they are also simple in design, and I love them. Your banner is out of this world, its really good. At first, I had no idea what your forum was about, but I think it get it now....sort of, lol. The use of browns is amazing. Great work. The only thing I don't like is the way you have your links displayed when the curser hovers over them. But thats just my personal prefrence. No one can make everyone happy anyways. I love your forum, its very good. You have done a wonderful job. [immortalironman]
transfermktforum said:
I like your ideas with the name and slogan. It is good. You have really got into it with the member groups and forum name bar. I like the banner and menu buttons, they are great! I like the skin and image on the left. The gradients are great too. The on/off icons work. You are really into that theme of nuts!How do you make names get bigger if you roll over them? Can you send me the code via PM?
The one thing I didn't like was the cell highlight. Darken it. But apart from that, it's truly fabulous!
[transfermktforum]
The following feedback was received from Zanmato Design:
sniperjrd said:
omg i love it!!its just that u need to change the gradients on the categories, maybe to a real red to yellow/orange gradient, with a picture of a leaf on the right and left. Thats all great job!
[sniperjrd]
Sarah said:
Hey april.Nice forum...Is active,and the designing looks nice.
I love the simple design and the images.I have no comments for it.
Great job April I really liked it.
My vote:8.9/10
[Sarah]
stormlrd said:
awesome looking site, wish i had have your graphics talent lol[stormlrd]
fred said:
It's an awesome site. I am a cruncher of it. Really great job there April![fred]
dopey85 said:
I think this is one of the tightest looking board I have seen for awhile. I'm sending you a PM.[dopey85]